A report on the Oregon health cost plan is in a 16 page supplement in the Hastings Center Report
(May/June 1991). Also see JAMA
266: 417-20, and BME
(June 1991), 32-5. A book review of John F. Kilner, Who Lives? Who Dies? Ethical Criteria in Patient Selection
(US$37.50, Yale University Press 1990), is in Lancet
337: 1400. It discusses rationing.
Comments on the USA health care system, or lack of it, are in Lancet
337: 1401-2, 338: 174-5; JAMA
265: 2998-3002, 3296-9, 3300, 266: 104-9, 399-401. See also J.E. Verby et al., "Changing
the medical school curriculum to improve patient access to primary care", JAMA
266: 110-3. They suggest choosing trainees who will reach the poorer portions of
the population, in primary care work. On the UK health care system see Lancet
337: 1588-90, and on the role of citizen's in the NHS see BMJ
303: 203-4. The question of whether doctors should set priorities is addressed in
Lancet
337: 1464. The second paper on the German health care system is in NEJM
324: 1750-7. A comment on the problems of Canada's health care system is in BMJ
303: 8.
A review is S.R. Benatar, "Medicine and health care in South Africa - five years later",
NEJM
325: 30-6. A discussion on what are the best hospital's for different specialities,
at least those perceived by physicians, in the USA is in U.S. News & World Report
(5 Aug 1991), 36+.
There continues to be a difference in the mortality of workers in different groups,
as seen in M.G. Marmot et al., "Health inequalities among British civil servants:
the Whitehall II study", Lancet
337: 1387-93.
Comments on President Bush's lack of doing anything about funding changes for health
care because it is politically safe is in Lancet
338: 561-2. On free clinics to treat the uninsured see JAMA
266: 838-40. On the Oregon health care budget; Lancet
338: 808-9; Archives of Diseases in Childhood
66: 990-3. On Maryland's plans to ration health care; BMJ
303: 670. Also see Lancet
338: 440; JAMA
266: 1123-4, 1215-6, 1510-1, 1562-5, 1566, 1570-2, 1901; NEJM
325: 198-200, 738-9; BMJ
303: 259-60; Archives of Diseases in Childhood
66: 997-9. A review of a book entitled Free to be Foolish: Politics and Health Promotion in the United States and Great Britain,
by Howard M. Leichter (Princeton 1991, 281pp., US$35) is JAMA
266: 1575.
On the costs of medical education in the USA see NEJM 325: 404-7. On how to pay for
expensive drugs in Britain under the NHS see BMJ
303: 593-4. On aging and rationing see BMJ
303: 869-70. On measuring inequalities in health care see Social Science & Medicine
33: 545-58; and R.J. Boys et al., "Mortality from causes amenable and non-amenable
to medical care: the experience of eastern Europe", BMJ
303: 879-83. Non-amenable causes are the principle cause of death, but many include
harm due to environmental causes.
On the NHS in Britain see Nature
353: 587-8; BMJ
303: 867-8. Changes to the health care schemes in many countries are underway; in
Australia and the U.K., BMJ
303: 485; in New Zealand, Lancet
338: 374-5, BMJ
303: 327; and in Sweden, BMJ 303: 267. In these countries with public health schemes,
the system is to switch to more private medicine. Although it may be complicated
by trying to reduce government spending, these governments don't seem to notice the
problems experienced in the USA with the coverage of private health insurance! They
also seem to have forgotten about the ethical ideals behind public health, and that
all people have a right to equal access to equal health care.
There are social inequalities in health in many countries. The case in Britain is
reviewed in BMJ
303: 1046-50; Lancet
338: 1059-63. Health care reform is a major issue in most countries, especially
in the USA, and many want health care for all; BMJ
303: 1011-3, 1221. The public and private expenditures on health care in industrialised
countries are listed in Lancet
338: 1259-60. The primary care comparisons between ten of these countries are compared
in JAMA
266: 2268-71.
Health rationing is one approach to saving costs, and some of the actualities in Britain
are discussed in BMJ
303: 1039-42; Lancet
338: 1133-4. Age-based rationing is discussed in JAMA 266: 3012-5. Some hope that
there may be better health care in a united Europe; BMJ
303: 1081-2, 1284. Health care reform in Sweden will be examine by a new commission;
BMJ
303: 1288. The Netherlands is also thinking of reexamining its health care; JAMA
266: 2215-7. See also BMJ
303: 1350. 77% of French people believe that they visit the doctor too often, and
other questions were examined in a recent poll of the French; SCRIP Notes
(11 Dec 1991), 3. In Britain, the government is encouraging the public to ask their pharmacists
more medical information instead of going to physicians, yet a recent consumer survey
found that poor advice was received from pharmacists; Times
(12 Dec 1991). Is this a veiled scheme to reduce the costs on the national health care
scheme by bringing in pharmacists to avoid some doctor's visits?
On US health care reform see JAMA
266: 2078-80, 2135-8, 2185, 2238-43, 2274, 2439-5, 3023-9; BMJ
303: 1216-7; NEJM
325: 1099-1100. On social science contributions in general to government decision
making see Science
254: 226-31.
The results of a recent survey in Britain on the popularity of the NHS is in Lancet
338 (1991), 1511-2. Like all statistics, they will be used in different ways by
politicians. In New Zealand the accident compensation scheme is changing, which
is being criticised by many; Lancet
338 (1991), 1583. It is a very efficient system internationally, partly because
only 6% is spent on administration, and it is a no fault system, but political change
is the mood of the government. Russia is intending to change its health care system
to, and make it decentralised like many other moves there; Lancet
339: 236. The province of Quebec in Canada is also changing its medical system;
BMJ
304: 72.
The costs of an aging population, and who should care for the elderly are discussed
in Lancet
339: 96-7, 294-5; 310. On rationing see BMJ
303 (1991), 1561-2; 304: 182. In the USA comment on health care resource allocation
is in JAMA
266 (1991), 3328-31.
On reform of the USA health care see E.R. Brown, "Health USA. A National Health Program
for the USA", JAMA 267: 552-8. A question of whether physicians should be given
incentives is addressed in JAMA
267: 403-5, and on fraud by US physicians against medicare; JAMA
266 (1991), 3318-22. For evidence of inequities in US health care; P.A. Braveman
et al., "Differences in hospital resource allocation among sick newborns according
to insurance coverage", JAMA
266: 3300-8. Related to the broader issues of inequality; V.R. Fuchs & D.M. Reklis,
"America's children: economic perspectives and policy options", Science
255: 41-6.
On general economic questions, including issues in the developing countries, and health
see BMJ
303 (1991), 1572-7. See also; R.G. Wilkinson, "Income distribution and life expectancy",
BMJ
304: 165-8. It looks at income within Britain, in addition to internationally.
On the financial crisis in Russian science see; Nature 355: 391. The USA has stepped
in and said that they will pay for some of the scientists. It is a waste to have
all the resources unused, both material and human resources.
On public opinion and the NHS in the
UK
see BMJ
304: 680-2, 892-4. The problems of medical insurers in the UK are discussed in BMJ
304: 458-9. Health policy had been one issue of the British election, we will wait
to see if any changes are made. A book review of media and health care is in Science
255: 1750.
In
New Zealand
the waiting lists for surgery and medical services have been growing rapidly following
the present government's policy, ironically aimed at reducing waiting lists; Christchurch Press
(4 March 1991), 33. The health care expenditures of different OECD countries are described
in BMJ
304: 770-1, and New Zealand follows Greece as the second lowest, while age expectancy
and perinatal mortality are reasonable good. However such type of analysis is too
simplistic. Rationing of health care is discussed in BMJ
304: 496-9, 716-7.
The socioeconomic health differences in the Netherlands are reviewed in Social Science & Medicine
34: 213-26. On income and health worldwide see BMJ
304: 715-5. An opinion survey in Finland asked people about different areas of government
spending which could be cut; Lancet
339: 813. Health care was valued the most among 12 options. US health costs are
discussed in papers in JAMA
267: 687-91, 945-8, 113-7, 1399, 1511-5, 1624-30, 1665-7, 1669-75, 1780; NEJM
326: 340-4, 565-9, 962-7; K.B. Weiss et al., "An economic evaluation of asthma in
the United States", NEJM
326: 862-6.
The large number of deaths due to tropical diseases and infectious diseases in developing
countries is the greatest discrepancy in health care funding, and some statistics
are shown in Science
256: 1135. The incidence of chronic disease is reported in Nature
356: 557-6. Public health expenditures in Sub-Saharan Africa (Botswana, Burkina
Faso, Cameroon, Ethiopia and Senegal) are analysed in Social Science & Medicine
34: 615-24.
In the USA, the NIH is spending US$45 million on a minority health acre initiative;
Science
256: 24. Ironically it is the minority thinking that is the cause of the worldwdie
injustice, because the minorities in the USA may be majorities worldwide. This word
"minority" should be removed from our thinking, as the world tries to become global
in outlook.
In New Zealand their is concern over the apparent increase in cot death rate amoung
Maoris, while the rate in those of European descent is falling; BMJ
304: 1074. The Maori rates in 1991 were about 20-40 times higher. Another comment
on New Zealand health statistics is in BMJ
304: 1330-1. A paper suggesting that health care resources as a whole do not make
a significant contribution to accounting for the variance of infant mortality rates
is K. Kim & P.M. Moody, "More resources better health? A cross-national perspective",
Social Science & Medicine
34: 837-42. Health care in Canada is reviewed in NEJM
326: 1469-72; and in Czechoslovakia in JAMA
267: 2461-6.
A special issue on rationing of health care in the USA is the AJLM
XVIII. It includes papers by D. Callahan, R.M. Veatch & C. Mason Spicer, D.C. Hadorn,
and S. Rosenbaum. Also on rationing see BMJ
304: 1440; and on Oregon's sytem for priority setting, JAMA
267: 1925-31, 1967. On inequalities in health care in the USA; JAMA
267: 2503-8; 2719; 2760-4; and on deciding which is the best health care payment
system (in the USA) a review is JAMA
267: 2509-20. medical liability is discussed in JAMA
267: 2355-8; 2487-92.
A review essay of P.T. Menzel, Strong Medicine,
is in Bioethics
6: 130-57, with author's response p. 158-65 and the so-called prior-consent theory,
based on distributive justice in medical care, is supported. The February issue
of Journal of Philosophy of Medicine
focuses on "Ethics and alternative health care systems".
Consideration of the prospects for rationing of health care in a Canadian context
are in Trends in Bioethics
(July 1992), 1-5. The way costs are calculated for the future is discussed in Lancet
340: 148-9. Cost effectiveness analysis is questioned in JAMA
267: 3342-8; and its ethics are questioned in JME
18: 7-11. A call for evaluation of all heath technology is made in BMJ
305: 67-8.
The US health care system is discussed in NEJM
326: 1715-20, 327: 274-7; JAMA
268: 344-5, 774-9. "Minority" group health in the USA, which is linked to health
care access is discussed in AJPH
82: 1079-81, 1082-4, 1168-70; Lancet
340: 346-50. The health care plans in Washington state in the USA to set maximum
premiums for health insurance, and to set up universal health care; HCR
(May-June 1992), 3. The whole issue will be voted in 1993, in addition to political changes
in the US elections.
Changes to the
New Zealand Accident Compensation Act
are reported in the Newsletter of the Otago Bioethics Research Centre
(Winter term 1992), 3-4. To save costs, there will be generally more limits on the
coverage of this no-fault accident compensation scheme, and reduced awards. No claims
against medical malpractice are allowed. In a US court decision, a woman who lost
two legs and an eye has been awarded US$5 million for compensation; Washington Post
(29 Aug 1992), C1. Health cost expenditure problems in Australia are taking an increasing
proportion of the government budget, from 13.6% in 1989-90 to 15.4% in 1993-4; MJA
156: 592-4. Changes to UK general practice are in BMJ
304: 1548-50; and on reforms in Germany; BMJ
304: 1650; and Czechoslovakia; BMJ
304: 1650-1.
The philosophical question of
age-based
differences and inequality is addressed in D. McKerlie, "Equality between age-groups",
Phil. & Public Affairs
21: 275-95. Discrimination is also addressed in D.C. Hadorn, "The problem of discrimination
in health- care priority setting", JAMA
268: 1454-9. It also discusses the Oregon health care plan (see below). Legal approaches
to cost-containment are discussed in L.I. Sederer, "Judicial and legislative responses
to cost containment", Amer. J. Psychiatry
149: 1157-61. The public versus private health care are debated; Lancet
340: 772-5.
Comments on the European Community proposals for health care are in R.H. Nicholson,
"divide and rule", HCR
(July-Aug 1992), 22: 5. The NHS in the UK and the issue of continuing care is discussed
in Lancet
340: 539-40. International health care approaches are commented on in Biotechnology
10: 1176; and global health independence is stressed in JAMA
268: 1462-3. On the cost containment problems of
Canadian
Medicare; BMJ
305: 705-6.
A review of the
Minnesota
Health Right program is in HCR
(Sept.-October), 22: 4-5. It aims at making health insurance affordable for more
people, and offers insurance at subsidised prices for those unable to pay. Also
on the US health care system see JAMA
268: 900-3, 916-8, 1265-6, 1332-6, 1588-94; Nature
359: 257-8; Lancet
340: 594-5, 717-8; NEJM
327: 742-7, 821-5; BMJ
305: 817-9. The
Oregon
test case and other state proposals for reform of health care are discussed in Science
257: 1202-3; NEJM
327: 642-4, 821; JAMA
268: 1267-8. President Bush vetoed the Oregon proposals, BMJ
305: 437-8; Lancet
340: 418. Drug prices in the USA have been said to be increasing too much by various
politicians; Lancet
340: 597-8. The presidential health care plans are compared in NEJM
327: 800-11.
A brief trial of user fees at a clinic in
Kenya
had a negative impact on health, S. Moses et al., "Impact of user fees on attendance
at a referral centre for sexually transmitted diseases in Kenya", Lancet
340: 463-6. Maternity services from Nigeria in Lancet
340: 732.
A review of no-fault compensation systems is J. Havard, "'No fault' compensation for
medical accidents", Medicine, Science & Law
32: 187-8.
The basic ethic involved in health care systems is that of beneficence, and justice.
If a country with sufficient resources fails to provide health care to its citizens
it is failing in these principles. A paper on these issues is C.J. Dougherty, "Ethical values at stake in health care reform", JAMA
268: 2409-12, 2352. The importance of health for children to learn is discussed
in JAMA
268: 1643; health care is a basic and fundamental human need.
For explanation and opposing views of ethicity of the changes in the
New Zealand
medical system see the Newsletter
of the University of Otago Bioethics Centre (Spring Term 1992) (P.O. Box 913, Dunedin,
New Zealand). Major structural changes are being made in the New Zealand health
care system, basically continuing the shift to privately-funded medicine. In the
same newsletter there are also descriptions of a new Mental Health Act, and changes to
the no-fault Accident Compensation Scheme. See also BMJ
305: 854.
A report on the system in
Japan
is N. Ikegami, "The economics of health care in Japan", Science
258: 614-8. The Ministry of Health and Welfare intends to try to introduce more
general practice ideas, as a screening for specialists in large hospitals; Yomiuri
Shinbun (4 Nov 1992), 3. However, teaching hospitals say this will take away patients
for student training. In Ibaraki prefecture, japan, up until October 1992 a total of 12 million
Yen in unpaid debts was owed by uninsured foreigners to hospitals; Yomiuri Shinbun
(18 Dec 1992), 22. The Prefecture government has said it will pay the debts, most of
which are owed by illegally working foreigners - who lack health insurance.
A report on the switch to private health care in former Eastern
Germany
is in BME
(Oct 1992), 33-5. On health care reform see: Germany, Lancet
340: 1216-7; BMJ
305: 909;
Italy
, Lancet
340: 1217; BMJ
305: 849
California
, BMJ
305: 1047;
London
, Lancet
340: 1070-1;
UK
, BMJ
305: 1248. A general comparison of the funding of several industrialised countries
on health care is in JAMA
268: 2032-3. The question of whether real change in health care and apartheid are
occuring in South Africa is reported in Lancet
340: 1324.
A comparison of the
Canadian
and
US
health care funding systems, and the need for change is W.W. Benjamin, "Combining
the best of two medical worlds: Canadian Universality and United States' Freedom",
Humane Medicine
8(4), 271-85; F.H. Lowy, "Restructuring health care: rationing and compromise", Humane Medicine
8(4), 263-7. Criticism of the Canadian government decision to dissolve the Law Reform
Commission is BME
(Oct 1992), 2, 4-5.
As reported in the last issue of the newsletter, the Oregon State Health plan received
a presidential veto, with the reason given that it may contradict with
anti
-
discrimination
measures of the American's with Disabilities Act (EEIN
2: 84). This veto is criticised in a legal commentary, A.M. Capron, "Oregon's disability.
principles or politics?", HCR
22 (6), 18-20. Some type of rationing is required, and quality of life decisions
should be a part of that. Another comment is P.T. Menzel, "Oregon's Denial. Disabilities
and Quality of Life", HCR
22 (6), 21-5. Reform of the US system is discussed in SA
(Nov 1992), 22-9; NEJM
327: 1090-5, 1245-6, 1310-15, 1463, 1467-72, 1525-8; JAMA
268: 2029-31, 2383-7, 2388-94, 2426-7, 2545-52; Lancet
340: 1086-7; BMJ
305: 878-80, 941-4, 1313.
Rationing
and cost-effectiveness are discussed in JAMA
268: 2050-4, 2139-41, 2142-3, 2575-82; BMJ
305: 1049, 1240-1; Science
258: 489-90; Lancet
340: 1343-4.
A paper arguing for the use of Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) in rationing health
care is K. Kappel & P. Sandoe, "QALYs, age and fairness", Bioethics
6: 296-316.
QALYs
are argued to be fair, and not to be against aged people. Additional comments on
the quality of life are in Bioethics
6: 356-64; BMJ
305: 875-7, 1074-7, 1145-8, 1205-9; and in the Euthanasia section.
The right to health care is the subject of a recent SCOPE note (#20), published in Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal
2 (1992), 389-405. A legal essay by G.J. Annas addresses a New York court case that
decided that people had to pay for unwanted medical treatment; NEJM
327 (1992), 1885-7. Risk-related health insurance is discussed in JAMA
269: 213-4.
The question of economies and bioethics is discussed in a French paper in IJB
3 (1992), 157-62. The treatment, alglucerase, for Gaucher's disease is very expensive,
and makes us ask again the question, "is no price to high?", NEJM
327 (1992), 1676-7. It can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars annually during
the first few years, is such a price justified? Not if we consider global justice,
and read about the tragedies of Africa; BMJ
305: 1479-80. The question of what technologies are suitable for developing countries
is asked in World Health Forum
13 (1992), 356-62. The August 1992 issue of J. Med. & Phil.
17 (1992), 367-480, looks at solidarity in health care. The effects of poverty on
health are reviewed in SSM
36: 157-66. A comparison of the access to health care is C.M. Grogan, "Deciding
on access and levels of care: A comparison of Canada, Britain, Germany, and the United
States", J. Health Politics, Policy and Law
17 (1992), 213-32. It draws out the US concept of minimum health care, whereas in
socialist countries all are entitled to the same health care.
In the next few month a new health care funding scheme in the
USA
is suggested. It appears likely that it will be the so-called "managed competition",
which includes the concept of minimum health care. Just how ethical it is depends
on what medical treatment is included in the US concept of minimum health care.
Managed competition may not work in rural districts, NEJM
328: 148-52, 133-5. Papers on national health schemes include: Lancet
340 (1992), 1458-9; NEJM
327 (1992), 1682-5; Science
259: 16-7, 105; NY State J. Med.
(Dec 1992), 513-5; JAMA
268 (1992), 3115-8, 3468-72,79; 269: 374-8, 498-501; J. Health Politics, Policy and Law
17 (1992), 233-53, 403-23; Int. J. Health Services
22 (1992), 381-96; Hospital Ethics
(Nov/Dec 1992), 1-4. A discussion of Minnesota's HealthRight law is in Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal
2 (1992), 201-16; JAMA
269: 511-5. The situation and plans in other state include:, Massachusetts, JAMA
269: 87-91; New Jersey, Lancet
341: 41; New York, BMJ
305 (1992), 1384; Oregon, JAMA
268 (1992), 3292. Rationing is discussed in Hospital Ethics
(Jul/Aug 1992), 13-6; (Sept/Oct 1992), 9-11; and poverty in Pediatric Nursing
18 (1992), 553-7.
The health funding and delivery systems in other countries are discussed in: U.K.,
BMJ
305 (1992), 1415-8, 306: 155-6, 166, 227-8, 381-2; Germany, BMJ
305 (1992), 1384-5; Hungary, J. Med. & Phil.
17 (1992), 455-62; Lancet
341: 43-4; the Netherlands, J. Med. & Phil.
17 (1992), 463-77. Financing of rural China in 1988 is discussed in SSM
36: 385-91. It was found that 5% of family income was spent on health, but access
was reportedly wide.
On the prior consent model of health care rationing see Bioethics Research Notes
4(1), 1-2.
A review on the rise of market led health financing, and the competition ideas, is
in Lancet
341: 805-12; see also Nature
362: 1, AJPH
83: 418-26, which defend the welfare ideal. A report on ethics and health care in
the
Czech
Republic is in BME
(Feb 1993), 13-6; on the crisis in funding shortages in
Bulgaria
, in BME
(Feb 1993), 17-9. The political problems in trying to change the
New Zealand
health care system are discussed in Lancet
341: 748-9, 885-6. The NZ Medical Association is opposed to the changes, involving
contracting in health. Political discussions on changes in
Australia
are discussed in BMJ
306: 783-7, 877-8; Lancet
341: 484-5. On the
Brazilian
system; BMJ
306: 503-6; the
Russian
system see BMJ
306: 909-11, 914-6; Lancet
341: 409; and
Lithuania
, p. 911-4. The changing situation in Albania is reported in BMJ
306: 446-7. Starvation is a problem more basic than medical health in many countries,
especially in Somalia; NEJM
328: 1055-61.
A comparison of primary care in the
UK
and
USA
is in NEJM
328: 940-5; and a book review on the situation in the Arab World is in BMJ
306: 662. The UK system is moving to fewer hospitals with bigger medical schools;
Lancet
341: 620-1; other comments on the UK include BMJ
306: 474, 647, 667-70, 673, 863. Canada is decentralising health care; Lancet
341: 483-4. Some US patients may come to the UK for discount treatment; BMJ
306: 539.
In public opinion polls in the
USA
, 78% believed that their health care system had failed, and 71% believed that it
was ready for a complete overhaul; BMJ
306: 739. Clinton has approved the Oregon rationing plan that Bush vetoed; BMJ
306: 811; Lancet
341: 817. Comments on the US health care system are in NEJM
328: 621-7, 651-4, 772-8, 805-7, 896-90, 892-3, 928-33, 961-3, 1129-30; Newsweek
(5 April 1993), 40-3; Lancet
341: 548, 682-3, 791-2, 816-7; Biotechnology
11: 434-5, 444-5. On the end-stage renal program see NEJM
328: 366-71; and on Minnesota health care reform, NEJM
328: 970-1. Hispanic and Latin health issues are discussed in JAMA
269: 1603. Plastic surgery is being performed as a tourist economy in Costa Rica,
CMAJ
148: 74-6.
In
Japan
, the local prefecture governments are having to pay for the medical treatment of
some foreigners without medical insurance. However, as noted before, if they have
HIV, they may be refused from some hospitals.
In
Japan
in 1991 people paid 21,800 billion yen for health.
On economics and life and death; SA
(May 1993), 18-25. On
ethical
issues and health costs; JAMA
269: 2116-21, 2558-62; NEJM
328: 1358-62; AJLM
(1992), 301-46.
Attitudes
of medical students in a Southwest US medical school to providing care for the poor
was found to decrease in fourth year students compared to first years; JAMA 269:
2519-23.
Papers on health care
rationing
: in the UK, Lancet
341: 1525; on health care reform in the USA; NEJM
328: 1208-12, 1489-93;JAMA
269: 2437-42, 2548-9, 2524-32, 2533-7, 2553-5, 2573-8; on states, Newsweek
(17 May 1993), 42-3,
Oregon
, Harvard Law Review
106: 1296-1313;
Hawaii
, JAMA
269: 2538-43. Health care in
Austria
is discussed in JAMA
269: 2789-94; in
Germnay
; BMJ
306: 1017-8.
The widely reported separation of
Siamese
twins at the Children's Hospital in Philadelphia, reportedly costing about $1 million,
could be considered a waste of money by many, as well as a crude example of experimental
excess. Two girls were separated, who shared a 6 chamber heart, with the automatic death of one. The longest survival of 5 cases is 3 and a half months, and the
outlook is dim.
Statistics show that
Canadians
spend less on health (US$1837 in 1990) compared to people in the US (US$2566), but
they have lower infant mortality and greater life expectancy. However, Sweden, Germany,
Finland and Denmark are better still. The development of guidelines to control expense is discussed in CMAJ
148: 913-7. Also on Canadian health care, Int. J. Health Sciences
23: 239-56; CMAJ
148: 2191-3; Trends in Bioethics
(July-Aug 1993), 1-3; Lancet
342: 102.
A series of papers on
US
health care reforms are in JAMA
269: 3136-9, 270: 198-200, 254-5, 377-8, 380-1; SA
(July 1993), 91; J. Health Politics and Policy
18: 1-174; Int. J. Health Sciences
23: 193-238, 257-78; NEJM
328: 1778, 329: 130-3, 372-6; Lancet
341: 1652; AJPH
83: 945-6; on
Oregon
health care, AJOG
168: 1870-4; AJLM
XIX: 1-144; BMJ
307: 373-7. One quarter of US hospital funds are spent on administration; NEJM
329: 400-3, 428-9;BMJ
307: 401. More papers on the US health care system and possibilities for reform
are in Health Care Analysis
1: 5-42.
Papers on the reforms in the
UK
NHS health system include: BMJ
306: 1703-4, 307: 73, 78-9, 81-2216-7, 280; Lancet
341: 1651 and on psychiatric care there, Nature
364: 657-8; BMJ
307: 248-50; also on psychiatry, JAMA
270: 252-3. Market reforms in
Sweden
are discussed in Int. J. Health Sciences
23: 185-8. The free health care in
Germany
is drawing refugees, CMAJ
148: 2184-6.
Poland
may have too many specialists and not enough general practitioners, CMAJ
148: 624-6. On the UK health reforms, in psychiatry, Nature
364: 90. A comparison of the
French
system with the
US
system for caring for uninsured persons is JAMA
270: 748-56. On European health care, BMJ
306: 1629-30.
On other countries see:
Netherlands
, Health Care Analysis
1: 43-56; SSM
37: 572-3, 833-9;
Israel
, BMJ
307: 219;
New Zealand
, BMJ
307: 219;
South Africa
, BMJ
307: 82. In New Zealand a survey of patient satisfaction with health care and hospitals
reported in the Consumer
(July 1993) found that in terms of the health care people are very satisfied with public
health care, as much as private health care, contrary to the views expressed by the
Government which wanted to change the system.
International
health articles include: JAMA
270: 629-31; AJPH
83: 941-3; Lancet
341: 1563-4, 342: 245; SSM
37(6): 697+; on war, JAMA
270: 600-5, 616-20, 632-3, 637-8; Lancet
342: 360. A list of overseas service organizations is in JAMA
270: 567-71.
A review is N.E. Adler, "Socioeconomic inequalities in health. No easy solution",
JAMA
269: 3140-5. There is increasing differences between the health of the rich and
the poor in the USA, in a study looking at 1960 and 1986; NEJM
329: 103-9. Lacking health insurance is shown to increase risk of mortality in JAMA
270: 326-31, 737-41. General comments on health costs are in Lancet
341: 1566-7, 342: 105-6; NEJM
329: 126-7, 321-5; BMJ
307: 140-1.
Research
and health costs are discussed in Science
261: 155, 416-8; Nature
364: 91; Amer. J. Med. Sciences
306: 5-9; JAMA
270: 43-5, 800-1; Lancet
342: 63-5, 99-100.
Feminist
views on enriching health care are in Humane Medicine
9: 201-6. The
environmental
issues are discussed in EST
27: 1242.
The refusal of several UK hospitals to treat nonurgent cardiac surgery in
smokers
was discussed in the Disease Risks section; see also Newsweek
(30 Aug 1993), 44. Papers on racial differences in the US health care system are in AJPH
83: 948-59.
A number of papers discus the reform of the
US
Health Care system; Nature
365: 281-2; BMJ
307: 813-4, 819-20;BME
(Aug 1993), 13-8; Newsweek
(27 Sept 1993), 42-5; Lancet
342: 732-3, 797, 815-6, 851-3; NEJM
329: 804-5, 880-6; JAMA
270: 927, 1357-62, 1449-53, 1513-6; Science
261: 1667. The plan to extend health care to all people in the US is an ethical
improvement on the current situation, but will cost much. The ethical case may be
summed up in the title of the paper, W.A. Glaser, "The United States needs a health
system like other countries", JAMA
270: 980-4. The
Oregon
priority listing approach has been experiencing delays in Oregon state; HCR
23(4), 6-7. See also a book review on the plan in Bioethics
7(4): 351-8.
Comparisons between
Canadian
health and the US situation are in NEJM
329: 964-6. On reform to the
UK
NHS see BME
(Aug 1993), 3-4; BMJ
307: 516-7, 750-1. A UK paper published lists of waiting times for treatment by
individual consultants, which is good for patient choice but upset the consultants,
BMJ
307: 699. The health care financing in different countries includes: New Zealand,
BMJ
307: 635-6;
Austria
, Lancet
342: 736;
Swiss
people have voted for a uniform hospital charge, that could result in a uniform
health cost system, Lancet
342: 857;
Chile
, BMJ
307: 729-30;
Nicaragua
, JAMA
270: 989-93. In
Cuba
the continued American embargo is threatening heath progress and an end has been
called for, BMJ
307: 521. In
Japan
the costs of medicines increased 7.7% last year, and 30% of hospitals are in the
red. Many are small hospitals, but the ones in the red are in big cities where costs
are higher, and mental hospitals where there is less income from drug prescriptions;
Yomiuri Shimbun
(30 Sept 1993), 3.
General papers on cost-benefit analysis in medicine are in BMJ
307: 670-3, 726-8, 793-5, 859-62, 924-6. On the ethics of public health medicine
see JRSM
86: 611.